Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie – A Nostalgic Dessert That’s Anything but Ordinary

There’s something oddly comforting about desserts that remind us of our childhood, and this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie does exactly that—only better. It takes everything you loved about the iconic toaster pastry and turns it into a full-blown pie that’s buttery, fruity, and glazed just like the original.

In this post, you’ll discover how to make this playful bake from scratch or semi-homemade with store-bought help. You’ll also find clever variations, storing tips, and a few dessert ideas if you’ve got extra Pop-Tarts on hand. Ready to turn a classic breakfast treat into your next showstopping dessert? Let’s dive in.

Where My Pop-Tart Obsession Began

Hi, I’m Abby! When I was little, nothing felt more indulgent than getting to pick my own Pop-Tart flavor at the grocery store. And nine times out of ten, I went with strawberry. There was something magical about the golden pastry, the jammy filling, and that sticky sweet glaze—especially when it was slightly toasted.

Years later, when I was working as a food stylist, I had this idea: what if I turned that handheld snack into a sliceable dessert? Enter this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie—a bake that brings together the nostalgia of breakfast and the comfort of a homemade pie.

It’s got a golden crust (flaky and rich), a gooey strawberry center made from real fruit and jam, and of course, that signature vanilla glaze with rainbow sprinkles. It’s playful, but with a grown-up twist. You can serve it at brunch, pack it in a lunchbox, or eat it straight from the pan with a fork—no judgment.

If you’re into desserts that are a little whimsical but still deeply satisfying, this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie is for you. It’s already become a reader favorite alongside some of my other no-bake and quick treats, and I can’t wait for you to try it.

Why This Recipe Works (and Why You’ll Love It)

At its heart, this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie is about making something fun that still tastes homemade. The crust is buttery and soft with just enough structure to hold the filling, while the inside is gooey, fruity, and layered with flavor thanks to a mix of strawberries and jam.

What really makes this pie sing is the glaze. It’s a simple mix of powdered sugar, vanilla, and milk, but it gives that glossy bakery finish and a hit of childhood nostalgia. A few rainbow sprinkles on top? Non-negotiable.

This recipe is a breeze to throw together, especially if you go the puff pastry or store-bought crust route. But if you’re in the mood to go all in, I’ll show you how to make the crust from scratch too.

You don’t need to be a pastry expert to get this one right. Whether you’re baking for a group of kids or just want a dessert that makes people smile, this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie delivers on every level.

And if you’re someone who lives for creative bakes, check out some of my other cookies and bars—you’ll love the mix-and-match filling options!

What You Need to Make a Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie

Essential Ingredients for Pop-Tart Perfection

The beauty of this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie is how easy it is to customize based on your pantry or how much time you have. Whether you’re going fully from scratch or keeping it semi-homemade, here’s everything you’ll need to recreate that iconic Pop-Tart flavor in pie form.

PIN IT

For the crust, you have a few options:

• Homemade pie dough – buttery, flaky, and totally worth it if you love a from-scratch bake.
• Store-bought pie crust – great for cutting time without sacrificing taste.
• Puff pastry – this creates a lighter, crispier crust with a beautiful golden finish. It’s an excellent choice for those wanting to replicate a homemade strawberry Pop-Tart with puff pastry.

For the filling, you’ll need:

• Fresh or frozen strawberries – chopped small for easier layering and a jammy texture once baked.
• Strawberry jam or preserves – to intensify the fruity flavor and add sweetness.
• Cornstarch or flour – helps thicken the filling so it doesn’t run when sliced.
• Lemon juice – brightens the strawberries and balances the sweetness.

And of course, no Pop-Tart-style dessert is complete without a glaze:

• Powdered sugar
• Vanilla extract
• Milk or cream – adjust to desired thickness.
• Sprinkles – classic rainbow jimmies for that playful bakery look.

This simple ingredient list brings major nostalgic energy while giving you the freedom to make it your own. Looking for shortcut-friendly bakes like this? You’ll find more in my no-bake and quick treats category, too!

Tools & Tips for Best Results

The tools for this pie are nothing fancy—but using the right ones makes all the difference in that final bake.

Here’s what you’ll want on hand:

• 9-inch pie dish or tart pan – metal or ceramic both work. If using puff pastry, consider a baking sheet for more surface area.
• Rolling pin – essential if you’re making dough from scratch or adjusting store-bought crusts.
• Pastry brush – for sealing the crust and brushing on an egg wash for shine.
• Fork or crimper – to press and seal the edges, mimicking that Pop-Tart border.
• Cooling rack – to help set the glaze once the pie is finished.

A few helpful baking tips:

• Chill your dough before baking for the flakiest crust.
• Don’t overfill the pie—leave about a half-inch border to seal it shut properly.
• Always cut a few slits or holes in the top crust to let steam escape and avoid sogginess.

Want to take things further? Use a small heart-shaped cookie cutter to make vents in the top crust for a playful design—like a love note baked into your pie. It’s the kind of personal touch that makes this recipe feel extra special, much like my other creative ideas over in cakes and cupcakes.

How to Make a Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie Step-by-Step

Assembly: Like a Giant Homemade Pop-Tart

Making this pie feels more like assembling an oversized Pop-Tart than baking a traditional fruit pie—and that’s exactly what makes it so fun.

PIN IT

Start by prepping your dough. If using store-bought crust or puff pastry, let it soften slightly at room temp so it’s easy to roll and shape. Roll it out to about 1/8 inch thick and trim the edges to create a large rectangle or oval, depending on your baking dish.

Place one sheet of dough into your greased pie dish (or lay it flat on a parchment-lined baking sheet for a more toaster-pastry look). Spoon your strawberry jam over the surface, leaving about a ½ inch border. Then layer on your chopped strawberries, a sprinkle of cornstarch, and a dash of lemon juice.

Top it with your second layer of dough and seal the edges by pressing with a fork or crimping them. Don’t forget to cut a few small slits in the top crust for steam to escape—this is key to avoiding soggy pie syndrome.

Brush the top crust with an egg wash (just 1 egg whisked with a splash of water) for that golden bakery shine. And if you’re feeling fancy, you can sprinkle on some coarse sugar before baking for an extra crunch.

Need more inspiration for layering flavor and texture? I’ve got a few cookie bar recipes that use similar jam layering techniques you might love exploring.

Bake It to Golden, Then Glaze It Pretty

Bake your Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie at 375°F (190°C) for 35–40 minutes, or until the crust is golden and the filling starts bubbling through the vents. If the edges start to brown too quickly, cover them with foil halfway through.

Let the pie cool completely before adding the glaze—this is crucial or it’ll just melt into the crust. While it cools, whisk together powdered sugar, a splash of milk, and vanilla extract until you get a smooth, pourable glaze.

PIN IT

Drizzle the glaze generously over the top, then immediately add sprinkles. This is the moment your giant Pop-Tart really comes to life. It should look like something straight from a vintage bakery case or a childhood dream.

Want to get creative with toppings? I often borrow flavor ideas from my favorite cakes and cupcakes—a drizzle of white chocolate, a pinch of freeze-dried strawberries, or even a touch of lemon zest in the glaze.

Once glazed, let it sit for about 15–20 minutes so the icing can firm up slightly. Then it’s ready to slice and serve—or devour straight from the tray. No judgment either way.

Variations, Storage, and Serving Ideas

Homemade or Hack? Choose Your Adventure

One of the best things about this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie is how flexible it is. Whether you’re a scratch baker or a shortcut queen, this dessert welcomes both paths with open arms.

If you’re leaning toward from-scratch, you can use a homemade pie crust or shortcrust pastry, sweetened just slightly to mimic the Pop-Tart shell. For an ultra-tender bite, try adding a spoonful of Greek yogurt to the dough—it adds richness and keeps things moist.

In a rush? Store-bought puff pastry is your best friend. It delivers that flaky, golden crunch and holds the filling beautifully. It’s also your go-to choice if you’re craving homemade strawberry Pop-Tarts with puff pastry but want to turn it into something shareable and sliceable.

Want to level up the flavor?
Here are some fun twists:

• Swirl in cream cheese with the jam for a cheesecake vibe.
• Add white chocolate chips to the filling for a sweeter finish.
• Use raspberry, blueberry, or mixed berry jam for a tart variation.
• Brush the top with a light lemon glaze instead of vanilla.

This recipe is also a great base for experimenting with other nostalgic snacks. I’ve got similar remix-style ideas in my no-bake and quick treats section, where familiar flavors get a creative spin.

How to Store, Freeze & Serve Pop-Tart Pie

This pie stores like a dream and tastes just as good the next day. Here’s how to keep it fresh and delicious:

To store:

• Keep it covered at room temperature for up to 2 days.
• Refrigerate for up to 5 days if using fresh fruit or cream cheese in the filling.

To freeze:

• Wrap unbaked pie tightly in plastic wrap and freeze for up to 2 months.
• Bake straight from frozen—just add an extra 10–15 minutes to the bake time.
• You can also freeze baked slices individually for quick snacks.

To serve:

PIN IT

• Warm it slightly in the microwave or a low oven for that gooey jam center.
• Serve with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, or even a drizzle of chocolate sauce.

For parties or brunches, slice the pie into mini rectangles and serve it Pop-Tart-style—boxed up in parchment like bakery goods. It’s a fun idea borrowed from my cookies and bars section where portable desserts shine.

This pie also makes an excellent make-ahead dessert for birthdays, potlucks, or even back-to-school celebrations. Whether you go full DIY or take a few delicious shortcuts, this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie never fails to impress.

Frequently Asked Questions About Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie

Conclusion

Whether you’re making it for a crowd, bringing back a childhood favorite, or just craving something sweet and a little nostalgic, this Strawberry Pop-Tart Pie hits all the right notes. It’s flaky, fruity, fun to make—and even more fun to eat.

With a few pantry staples and a little creativity, you can turn this pie into a signature bake of your own. And if you’ve got a soft spot for desserts that make people smile, this one definitely belongs in your recipe box.

For more colorful, health-forward creations and behind-the-scenes peeks into my test kitchen, connect with me on Facebook and see what’s brewing daily on Pinterest. Your next favorite recipe might just be a scroll away.

Print