Creepy Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes That Everyone Will Love

There’s something thrilling about creepy desserts during spooky season—and nothing steals the show like Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes. These eerie treats look just like bloodshot eyeballs staring straight at you, but one bite reveals soft, fluffy red velvet cake and sweet vanilla frosting. In this post, I’ll walk you through how to make these eye-catching cupcakes from scratch or with a box mix, how to model the edible eyeballs with fondant, and the tips to get the best spooky effect. Whether you’re planning a Halloween party or just want a fun baking activity, these cupcakes will be the scream of your table.

The Story Behind My Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes

A Bake That Watches You Back

One chilly October afternoon, with storm clouds brewing and Halloween around the corner, I decided it was time to level up my spooky treat game. I had just styled a batch of Bloody Eyeball Candy Apples for a shoot and wanted something creepier… but softer. That’s when I remembered the red velvet cake mix from Tasty Me sitting in my pantry. Not my usual scratch-made go-to, but perfect for a quick experiment.

I added butter and eggs, baked the batter into muffins, and was shocked at how beautifully they rose—not too dense, not too dry. The color was eerily perfect, just like the filling in my Vampire Fudge, and instantly gave me the idea: eyeballs. Snowy domes of white frosting, topped with handmade fondant eyes, each with a glossy red “vein” oozing down the sides.

Why Augapfel Cupcakes Are the Halloween Showstopper

“Augapfel” means eyeball in German—and let’s be honest, these cupcakes are unforgettable. They sit there watching you, drawing gasps, laughs, and “ewws!” before guests even take a bite. What I love most is how they blend creepy aesthetics with incredible flavor. The red velvet base is rich and soft, while the fondant and piping gel combo gives you creative freedom to go full horror—or stay cartoon cute.

They’re also surprisingly simple to pull off, especially with kids. My niece loved helping draw the blood vessels and pressing the pupils into the fondant. It’s an edible craft project wrapped in a cupcake wrapper, and a must-have for your next haunted gathering.

Eyeball Decorations: From Fondant to Frightening

What You’ll Need to Make Spooky Eyeballs

If you want your Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes to look as gruesome as they taste delicious, the fondant eyeballs are key. You’ll need white fondant as the base, mixed with a little CMC powder so the eyeballs keep their shape. For the iris and pupil, use colored and black fondant. Then grab edible food pens or red gel for the veins, and a touch of piping gel to give your eyes that glossy, wet look.

It’s a similar approach I used for the gooey, detailed center in my Jello Brains, only this time it’s scaled down to bite-sized, spooky fun. Don’t forget tools like a ball tool or small spoon for shaping, and a soft brush for applying the gel without smudging your work.

Pro tip: Don’t stress if you’re not a fondant expert. These eyeballs are surprisingly forgiving to make—and honestly, the messier the veins, the better they look.

How to Model Your Fondant Eyeballs

Start by rolling the white fondant into smooth spheres—these will be your eyeballs. Press a small indent into each using a ball tool. Add a flat disc of colored fondant into the center to form the iris. Top it off with a small black fondant ball, gently pressed, to form the pupil.

Next, use edible food pens to draw thin red veins starting from the iris and fanning outward. Don’t overthink it—random is scary. Then coat each eyeball with a thin layer of clear piping gel. This step gives them the slimy, wet effect that really sells the illusion. You can also tint some of the gel red and trace over a few veins for more gore.

Let the eyeballs dry overnight on parchment paper. This gives them time to firm up, just like the components in my Halloween Dunkaroo Dip, which also balances creepy with crave-worthy.

Base & Topping: What Makes These Cupcakes Work

Red Velvet, Vanilla, or Chocolate?

When it comes to Halloween cupcakes, red velvet is the ultimate choice—it’s eerie, vibrant, and rich in flavor. For my Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes, I used a boxed Red Velvet mix from Tasty Me. It saved me time and had just the right bloody hue to match the spooky vibe. The texture came out light and fluffy, which made a perfect base for holding up the heavy eyeball decorations.

That said, chocolate or vanilla cupcakes work great too. In fact, for something milder in flavor, I sometimes fall back on this Witches Brew Swirl Cheesecake recipe base and convert it into cupcakes—it’s colorful, fun, and pairs wonderfully with Halloween décor. You can also experiment with natural colors or dark cocoa for a deeper, more haunting look.

Whatever you choose, make sure to bake them evenly. Fill your liners about two-thirds full and don’t overbake—dry cupcakes won’t hold the decorations well. Let them cool fully before decorating or the fondant eyes will slide right off.

Smooth, Snowy Frosting for the Eyeballs

The frosting acts as the cushion for your edible eyeballs, so it needs to be thick, creamy, and pipeable. I used Creme Fantastique (also from Tasty Me), which whipped into a bright white, buttercream-like texture. It held its shape incredibly well, which is essential when you’re placing something as detailed as a fondant eye on top.

To pipe it, use a large round nozzle and swirl on a generous dome. Then, use the back of a teaspoon to create a small divot in the center—just like the textured tops I did with my Creepy Deviled Eggs. This creates a perfect nest for your eye to sit in. Don’t forget to drip a little red piping gel down the sides to make the “blood” effect even more convincing.

Pro tip: You can also flavor your frosting subtly with vanilla or almond extract to keep the taste from being overly sweet.

Serving, Storing & Sharing These Eyeball Cupcakes

Party Presentation That Pops

The fun doesn’t stop at baking—presentation is everything when it comes to Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes. Picture a moody cake stand layered with spooky fabric or cobwebs, surrounded by creepy props like plastic spiders or potion bottles. These cupcakes look incredible on display, especially with glossy eyeballs staring back at your guests.

I always pair them with other Halloween sweets like Frankenstein Brownies and themed party bites for a dessert table that’s both festive and photogenic. If you’re planning a spooky buffet, stagger them on multiple cake plates at varying heights to create dimension.

One detail I love? Cut one cupcake in half and leave it on display. The red velvet interior mimics “blood” and adds an unexpected shock when people realize it’s edible. You’ll hear lots of “eww!” followed by “can I try one?”

Make-Ahead Tips & Storage

The good news is that Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes are as practical as they are showy. You can bake the cupcakes 1–2 days ahead and store them in an airtight container at room temperature. Just make sure they’re completely cooled before sealing.

The fondant eyeballs should be made at least 24 hours before use so they can firm up. I store mine uncovered on parchment paper in a cool, dry place. Don’t refrigerate fondant—it tends to sweat and melt details.

Frosting can be prepped a day in advance too. Keep it in the fridge and re-whip it briefly before piping. Once assembled, the finished cupcakes can last up to 2–3 days in the refrigerator. I recommend adding the eyes and “blood” the day of serving to keep everything fresh and intact.

Want even more spine-tingling treats to serve alongside? These Bloody Red Velvet Popcorn bags make a fun, crunchy sidekick—and they pack just as much Halloween flair.

Frequently Asked Questions about Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes

Final Thoughts: Creepy, Delicious, and Crowd-Pleasing

Halloween Augapfel Cupcakes are everything spooky baking should be—playful, a little gross, and a lot of fun. They combine baking basics with edible crafting, making them the ultimate creative dessert. Whether you go full DIY or use a box mix, the joy is in the decorating. Each cupcake becomes a little eyeball personality on its own, perfect for delighting (or mildly horrifying) your guests.

They also store well, travel easily, and make the perfect addition to any Halloween dessert spread—especially when paired with other creepy creations like Halloween Blut Cakepops or Monster Cookies mit Schokolinse. So get your fondant ready, grab your piping gel, and bake something that’ll have everyone doing a double take.

If you bake it, I’d love to see your creations — share them with me on Facebook or save this recipe to your Pinterest board for later inspiration.

Print