Frozen Cherry Vanilla Cola: A Cool and Nostalgic Treat You’ll Crave

When the sun’s blazing and you’re craving something sweet, fizzy, and a little indulgent, nothing hits quite like a frozen cherry vanilla cola. This icy twist on a nostalgic favorite brings together the best of cherry cola and creamy vanilla with a refreshing frozen texture you’ll want to sip all summer long. Whether you’re missing the discontinued Cherry Vanilla Coke or just in the mood for something deliciously different, this easy homemade version is your answer.

In this article, we’ll walk through how to make the perfect frozen cherry vanilla cola, share insider tips, and answer common questions about the flavor we all love.

How Frozen Cherry Vanilla Cola Brings Back Summer Memories

There’s something about the first sip of a frozen cherry vanilla cola that instantly transports me back to my childhood. I remember lazy August afternoons with the radio humming in the background, a paper cup sweating in my hand, and that iconic blend of cherry and vanilla dancing across my tongue. It was the taste of summer freedom, of bike rides and sunburnt shoulders. Years later, when Coca-Cola quietly pulled Cherry Vanilla Coke from shelves in certain areas, I was devastated. That familiar flavor had become a little harder to find—and that’s exactly why I decided to make my own frozen cherry vanilla cola at home.

The beauty of this drink is that it’s both retro and refreshing. It takes just a handful of ingredients to recreate a flavor that’s instantly recognizable, yet still feels a little magical. Whether you remember sipping Cherry Vanilla Coke from a fountain machine or you’ve only recently discovered it in the freezer aisle of a gas station, there’s something deeply comforting about that combination. My frozen version amps up the nostalgia with a slushy twist that’s perfect for cookouts, pool parties, or even a quiet evening on the porch.

You’ll find that making your own frozen cherry vanilla cola isn’t just simple—it’s a bit of a throwback ritual. You get to pick your ingredients, blend everything to just the right texture, and top it off with all the garnishes you love. And the best part? You don’t have to wait for your local store to restock. You can bring this nostalgic treat back to life anytime you like, right in your own kitchen.

If you love reimagining old favorites, you’ll also enjoy recipes like the Frozen Strawberry Lemonade Tart and my No-Churn Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, both designed with the same blend of cozy creativity.

What Inspired This Frozen Treat Recipe

The original Cherry Vanilla Coke may be hard to find these days, but that didn’t stop me from chasing the flavor. After experimenting with frozen cola cubes, tart cherries, and pure vanilla extract, I finally landed on a recipe that brought back all the feelings I missed. This frozen cherry vanilla cola is more than just a drink—it’s a way to recreate memories, stir up nostalgia, and cool off in the tastiest way possible.

I wanted to create something that wasn’t overly sweet, still sparkled with cola flavor, and had that smooth vanilla undertone that makes every sip linger a little longer. The cherries, especially when you freeze them, add just the right burst of fruitiness without overwhelming the cola. A splash of fresh lime or a swirl of whipped cream on top can take it over the edge into “treat-yourself” territory.

And if you’re anything like me, you’ll find that this drink doesn’t just satisfy a craving—it starts a craving. That’s why I keep frozen cola cubes and a bag of pitted cherries in the freezer at all times. It’s a quick blend away from summertime in a glass.

Don’t miss other creative frozen favorites like my Peach Cobbler Milkshake and the crowd-pleasing Salted Caramel Cold Brew Float—each one blending comfort and flavor in every chilled sip.

Creating the Perfect Frozen Cherry Vanilla Cola at Home

Ingredients That Capture That Classic Flavor

To nail the flavor of a frozen cherry vanilla cola, you need just a few high-impact ingredients. The key is balance—between sweetness, fizz, tartness, and creaminess. You don’t need to overthink it, but choosing quality ingredients does make a big difference.

Here’s what you’ll need:

PIN IT

• 1½ cups frozen pitted cherries (tart or dark sweet cherries both work; tart gives a brighter punch)
• 1½ cups cola, chilled (Coca-Cola or Pepsi both work—use your personal favorite)
• 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract (or vanilla syrup for a sweeter version)
• 1½ cups frozen cola cubes (just pour cola into ice cube trays and freeze overnight)
• Optional: 1 oz cherry liqueur or 2 oz vanilla rum for an adult twist

These ingredients together create a slushy that mimics the classic cherry vanilla soda flavor but with an elevated, icy texture. Freezing cola into cubes may seem like an extra step, but it makes the texture more authentic without diluting the drink.

If you want a non-alcoholic version, just skip the liqueur and go heavier on the vanilla extract or use a splash of cherry juice for extra intensity.

For more frozen fun, don’t miss the Frozen Blueberry Cheesecake Shake—a similar blend of creamy, fruity, and icy perfection.

Also Read: Chia Pudding Recipe with Yogurt: Easy, Creamy Breakfast

Step-by-Step: How to Blend Your Drink Just Right

Making this frozen cherry vanilla cola couldn’t be easier, but there are a few small tricks that make a big difference. Here’s how I do it:

PIN IT

1. Start by adding your frozen cherries and frozen cola cubes to the blender. This forms the icy base of your drink.
2. Pour in the chilled cola—don’t overdo it or your mixture will get too runny. Start with about half the liquid and add more as needed.
3. Add vanilla extract and any liqueur if you’re making a cocktail version.
4. Blend on high until the mixture is smooth but still slushy. If it’s too thick, splash in a little more cola.
5. Taste and adjust—add a few extra cherries for tartness or a dash more vanilla for a creamier vibe.

You’re looking for a consistency somewhere between a slushie and a milkshake. It should be spoonable, not sippable, but melt beautifully on the tongue.

Serve immediately in chilled glasses. Garnish with a dollop of whipped cream, maraschino cherries, or even a little vanilla sugar around the rim for a fancy finish.

Want to try another icy retro remake? Check out my Root Beer Float Cupcakes—same vibes, baked instead of blended.

Cherry Vanilla Cola FAQs – Solving the Mystery Behind the Drink

Is Cherry Vanilla Coke Still Around in 2025?

This is probably the most common question from fans of the original. As of 2025, Cherry Vanilla Coke has become increasingly hard to find, and in many regions, it’s no longer stocked in major retailers. While Coca-Cola hasn’t issued a global discontinuation notice, distribution has slowed dramatically, especially for the canned variety. It was initially launched as a fusion of two beloved soda flavors, but due to shifting product strategies and limited shelf space, it quietly disappeared from many stores.

So, if you’ve been wandering grocery aisles wondering, “Is vanilla coke discontinued in 2025?” — the short answer is: some versions are, yes. Regular Vanilla Coke and Cherry Coke can still be found, but the combo version is rarely seen and may only return seasonally or in limited markets. This lack of clarity from Coca-Cola has left many fans frustrated and craving a way to recreate the drink themselves.

That’s exactly why this frozen cherry vanilla cola recipe exists—to bring back a nostalgic favorite that you can no longer rely on finding in stores. If you’re looking for more discontinued drink revivals, don’t miss my Homemade Crystal Pepsi Float, another fun trip back in time.

What Does Cherry Vanilla Taste Like?

If you’ve never had it, cherry vanilla is a flavor fusion that’s both bold and smooth. Imagine the deep, syrupy sweetness of black cherries paired with the mellow, creamy warmth of real vanilla. It’s like soda meets dessert—in the best possible way.

Here’s a quick breakdown of the flavor notes:

Flavor Element	Taste Profile
Cherry	Sweet-tart, fruity, bold
Vanilla	Smooth, creamy, soft spice
Cola	Caramel, citrusy, fizzy bite

The result is a drink that’s fun, layered, and a little indulgent—which is why so many people miss the original Cherry Vanilla Coke. Fortunately, our frozen version gives you the same nostalgic kick, with even more texture and flavor complexity thanks to real fruit and vanilla.

Still wondering why you can’t find it anymore? It’s part of a larger trend where brands like Coca-Cola discontinue niche flavors to streamline production. In 2024, flavors like Orange Vanilla Coke and Diet Coke Feisty Cherry were also retired. So, when you ask “Which Coke is being discontinued?” — chances are it’s one of those beloved limited-run flavors.

This is why DIY recipes are essential for soda lovers who refuse to say goodbye. For another custom twist, try my Cherry Bourbon Cola Glaze over grilled chicken—it uses the same flavor profile, but in savory form.

Serving & Customization Ideas

Frozen Cherry Vanilla Cola for Every Occasion

The beauty of this frozen cherry vanilla cola recipe is how easily it flexes for any moment. Want something nostalgic and fun for a weekend barbecue? Done. Hosting a retro-themed dinner with friends? This drink practically begs for a comeback. You can even serve it as a mocktail for kids or add a spirited twist for the adults in the room.

Here’s how to tailor it:

• For kids and teens: Keep it classic—frozen cola cubes, cherries, vanilla extract, and maybe a whipped cream swirl. Serve in fun glasses with striped paper straws.
• For brunch or dessert: Add a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream on top to turn it into a float-slush hybrid. It’s indulgent without being overly heavy.
• For grown-up gatherings: Add 1–2 oz of vanilla rum, cherry vodka, or bourbon. The booze adds depth without overpowering the nostalgic flavors. I recommend Blue Chair Bay Vanilla Rum or Luxardo Cherry Liqueur for top-tier taste.

PIN IT

Planning a summer party? Pair this drink with S’mores Ice Cream Sandwiches or Mini Cherry Cheesecake Jars for a match made in backyard heaven.

Tips to Elevate Your Drink Presentation

You’ve nailed the flavor—now let’s talk about the look. Presentation turns a simple frozen drink into something memorable, and trust me, your guests (and your camera roll) will thank you.

Here’s how to style it like a pro:

• Garnish with flair: Add skewers of frozen cherries or a curled orange peel for contrast. A few mint leaves or even a rim of vanilla sugar can add elegance.
• Layer it up: Pour in a splash of plain cola over the slush just before serving—it creates a cool ombré effect in the glass.
• Use clear or vintage glassware: Retro soda glasses, mini milk bottles, or even mason jars make a statement without trying too hard.
• Serve ice-cold: Keep your glasses in the freezer for 10 minutes before pouring in the slush. It helps maintain the perfect texture longer.

And for those who love to turn every sip into a moment, try this drink alongside a cozy snack like Brown Butter Snickerdoodle Bars—the warm spice complements the chilled cherry vanilla beautifully.

FAQs About Cherry Vanilla Coke

Conclusion

Frozen cherry vanilla cola is more than a drink—it’s a memory in a glass. Whether you grew up sipping Cherry Vanilla Coke from a soda fountain or you’re discovering it now for the first time, this recipe brings back everything we love about the flavor: the fizz, the fruitiness, the creamy vanilla backdrop, and that icy, refreshing chill.

Now you don’t have to wait for Coca-Cola to bring it back—you can blend up your own nostalgic version whenever the craving hits. Perfect for summer gatherings, cozy nights in, or just when you want a little sip of the past.

Want more throwback-inspired recipes? Don’t miss my Raspberry Creamsicle Cake or Classic Malt Shop Milkshake Trio.

For more colorful, health-forward creations and behind-the-scenes peeks into my test kitchen, connect with me on Facebook and see what’s brewing daily on Pinterest. Your next favorite recipe might just be a scroll away.

Print