The Memory Behind This Treat
The first time I tried making Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream, I was coming off a long travel week where I’d lived on airport salads and protein bars. I walked into my kitchen craving something that felt like a real dessert, not another “healthy but sad” snack. The carton of high-protein milk was staring at me, my Ninja Creami pint was clean and waiting, and there was a half-empty sleeve of chocolate sandwich cookies on the counter from my kids’ after-school snacks. That’s when the light bulb went off: what if I could have that nostalgic cookies-and-cream flavor I grew up with, but in a bowl I didn’t have to feel weird about eating on a random Tuesday night?
When I spun that first test batch, it wasn’t perfect. The protein base was creamy but I’d been too shy with the sweetener, and it tasted more like “protein shake in a snowstorm” than ice cream. So I went back, adjusted the sugar-free pudding mix and sweetener, added a little Greek yogurt for body, and tried again the next day. This time when I opened the Creami, the texture looked like real ice cream: smooth, scoopable, and just thick enough to hold those crumbled cookies. I remember calling my husband into the kitchen, handing him a spoon, and not telling him it was high protein until after he’d gone back for a second bite.
Now, this Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream has become our “reward bowl” after family walks, late-night dishwashing marathons, and sometimes right alongside a slice of high-protein banana bread on Sunday afternoons. I love that it starts with simple staples you probably already have: protein powder, flavored pudding mix, and a splash of extract. Once you see that your everyday protein shake can turn into this nostalgic, speckled bowl of cookies-and-cream goodness, it changes how you look at dessert. It feels a little bit like cheating the system—in the best possible, extra-creamy way.
How To Make It (Mix & Ingredients)
To make a perfect base for Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream, start with 1½ cups of high‑protein milk like Fairlife skim or 2%. This gives you great protein and a naturally creamy texture without needing heavy cream. To that, add 1 scoop (25–30 g) of protein powder—whey makes a lighter, fluffier ice cream, while casein or a whey–casein blend gives you a thicker, almost custardy feel. Sprinkle in 2–3 teaspoons of sugar‑free instant pudding mix (vanilla works great for cookies and cream), which acts like a stabilizer and helps your pint stay scoopable instead of icy. Finish the base with 1–2 teaspoons of sweetener (I like allulose for the best texture) and a splash of vanilla extract; taste the mixture before freezing and adjust sweetness so it’s just a touch sweeter than you think it should be—freezing dulls flavors.
Instructions Process of Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream
Once your base tastes good, you’re ready to blend. Add the milk, protein powder, pudding mix, sweetener, and extract to a blender and blend until completely smooth—no dry clumps at the bottom, no powder stuck to the sides. If you want extra richness, blend in 2–3 tablespoons of Greek yogurt or blended cottage cheese; it won’t make it taste tangy once frozen, it just adds a velvety finish like my favorite high‑protein cheesecake mixtures. Pour the smooth base into your Ninja Creami pint, leaving just a little headspace at the top so it doesn’t overflow when you spin. Freeze the pint on a flat surface for at least 24 hours, then spin on Lite Ice Cream or Creami. If it looks crumbly after the first spin, add 1–3 tablespoons of milk, hit Re‑Spin, and then gently fold in your chopped chocolate sandwich cookies so every bite of your Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream has those dark, chocolatey flecks and creamy vanilla swirls.
Make-Ahead & Storage
One of my favorite things about these Ninja Creami protein pints is how well they fit into real life. You can prep a few base pints on Sunday, freeze them, and spin a fresh “just-made” dessert any night of the week. For most flavors—including Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream—the base needs a full 24 hours in the coldest part of your freezer to freeze solid. If you batch prep, label each pint with the flavor and date so you’re not guessing what’s what three days later. I also like to leave ½ inch of headspace at the top of the pint so the mixture can expand as it freezes without warping the lid.
Once you’ve spun your pint, treat it like soft-serve: the texture is best right away. If you need to store leftover Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream, smooth the top with a spoon, press a small piece of parchment directly on the surface to limit ice crystals, and pop the lid back on. You can refreeze and re-spin once or twice, but every round of freezing will make it a bit icier, especially if you use whey protein only. For chunkier flavors—like cookie dough, brownie bits, or candy-loaded pints—stir the mix-ins in after spinning and eat those batches within 1–2 days so the mix-ins stay crisp and don’t go stale in the freezer. If you love having options, keep a few plain vanilla protein bases ready, then flavor and mix-in after spinning to turn one simple base into everything from mint chip to cookies and cream in under 5 minutes.
Best Ingredients & Party Variations
When you’re playing with Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream, the ingredients you start with make the difference between “eh, it’s fine” and “wait, this is actually protein?” For the base, I like high-protein milk such as Fairlife because it keeps the texture thick and scoopable instead of icy. Pair that with a whey–casein blend or straight casein protein powder for extra creaminess—pure whey can sometimes churn up a little airy and icy in the Creami. That tiny bit of sugar-free instant pudding mix pulls double duty: it thickens the mixture and gives you that almost custardy mouthfeel you usually only get from full-fat ice cream. A splash of vanilla extract (or even butter vanilla if you have it) really lifts the “cookies and cream” flavor without needing extra sweetener.
Now for the fun part: party variations that actually work with a high-protein base. For a classic cookies-and-cream moment, fold in crushed chocolate sandwich cookies after spinning—start with 2 cookies for a macro-friendly pint and go up to 4–5 for full celebration mode. You can do a “birthday party” version by adding almond extract to the base and stirring in crushed golden sandwich cookies and sugar-free sprinkles after the spin. If you like things more intense, swirl in 1–2 tablespoons of chocolate syrup or a chocolate protein frosting-style drizzle right before serving. I also love a “mocha cookies and cream” twist: use coffee-flavored protein powder, a little extra sweetener, and add your cookie pieces plus a teaspoon of mini chocolate chips at the end for a texture that feels like it belongs in a fancy scoop shop.
Serving of Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream
Conclusion
If you’ve made it this far, you and I are officially kindred dessert spirits. There’s something so simple and quietly joyful about whirring up a pint, grabbing a couple of spoons, and watching everyone’s eyes light up at that first cold, creamy bite. Desserts don’t have to be fancy to feel special—they just need to taste good and be shared with people you love. That’s the real magic behind these protein-packed Ninja Creami creations.
I’ve lost count of the late-night chats and lazy Sunday afternoons that started with, “Want to make ice cream?” and turned into real, memory-making moments. Whether you’re blending for your kids after soccer, for your partner on the couch, or just for yourself after a long day, this little ritual of scooping, swirling, and topping is a small act of care. A bowl of Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream has a way of turning an ordinary day into a mini celebration.
For more delicious recipes like this, follow us on social media!
Which protein powder works best for Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream?
Whey protein usually gives the smoothest, fluffiest result for Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream. Casein makes the texture a bit thicker and more “pudding-like,” which some people love for a denser bowl. Blends of whey and casein can offer a nice middle ground—creamy and stable, especially if you like to re-freeze leftovers. If your protein powder is very sweet, cut back on added sweetener the first time you make the recipe. For a more neutral flavor, choose vanilla or unflavored; chocolate or cookies-and-cream powders will give you a deeper, more dessert-like vibe. If your powder tends to clump, pre-blend it with a little milk before adding everything else.
Recipe
Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream
Ingredients
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 cups high-protein milk Fairlife skim or 2%
- 1 scoop 30 g vanilla protein powder (whey, casein, or blend)
- 3 tsp sugar-free instant vanilla pudding mix
- 2 tsp allulose or other granulated sweetener
- 1/2 tsp vanilla bean paste
- 3 tbsp plain Greek yogurt
- 2 chocolate sandwich cookies chopped
- 1 –3 tbsp high-protein milk for re-spin if needed
Instructions
- Add the high-protein milk, protein powder, sugar-free pudding mix, sweetener, vanilla bean paste, and Greek yogurt to a blender.
- Blend on high until the mixture is completely smooth and no dry powder remains on the sides or bottom.
- Pour the blended mixture into a Ninja Creami pint container, leaving a little space at the top.
- Cover the pint and place it on a flat surface in the coldest part of your freezer for 24 hours, until fully solid.
- After freezing, remove the lid and place the pint into the Ninja Creami outer bowl and lock it into the machine.
- Run the Lite Ice Cream or Ice Cream cycle according to your machine’s instructions.
- Check the texture; if it is crumbly or powdery, add 1–3 tbsp high-protein milk to the center of the pint.
- Run a Re-Spin cycle until the ice cream is smooth and creamy.
- Remove the pint from the machine and gently fold in the chopped chocolate sandwich cookies until evenly distributed.
- Serve immediately as soft-serve style or return to the freezer for 10–15 minutes for a firmer texture.
Notes
- Allulose tends to give the smoothest texture, but you can use monk fruit or stevia blends if preferred.
- If you skip the Greek yogurt, the ice cream will still work but may be slightly less creamy.
- For smaller cookie pieces throughout, chop the sandwich cookies finely; for big bites, break them into larger chunks.